reality blurred: reality tv reviews, reality show recaps, and news

Get my reality TV reviews, recommendations, and analysis in your inbox most Fridays:  

Latest stories

The 12 Angry Men of Lumet's best-regarded film. Is THAT true crime? (Orion-Nova Productions)

How much true crime is on Sidney Lumet’s c.v.?

The Best Evidence True-Crime Résumé Percentage tackles its first director, plus confronting the definition of “major case” (and a bad Vin Diesel hairpiece).

A person gestures with open hands while standing outside next to a large gourd

Are Survivor 48’s players going to let an alliance and/or a duo run to the end?

There are some obvious, open alliances on Survivor 48, and while episode 8 had some interesting pushback against those, right now, it’s not clear if there will be action. Here’s my recap!

Two people sitting next to each other in a car; one has their eyes closed. The subtitle says "Stop crying."

Amazing Race’s Jonathan explains his ‘extreme reactions’: he has autism

Amazing Race 37’s Jonathan has become this season’s villain for his cruelty toward his wife, Ana, and other behavior. He now understands why he behaved that way, but says it is “not an excuse.”

Two people sit on a couch and talk; the person on the left gestures widely

Three recommendations, a two-week break

This week: A super-brief episode with three fast recommendations because I cannot actually talk, so apologies for having to listen to 50 seconds of this.

Two people shake hands over a table while a third walks toward them

Can The Floor contestants do internet research?

How are The Floor players assigned categories, and can they research their own and others’ categories? I have the answers.

A close-up of a person's face; they're wearing a green cap and have their tongue poking through their lips

Captain Jason cuts out Below Deck’s infection but denies us catharsis

Below Deck Down Under season 3 captain Jason finally did something about his awful bosun, who still didn’t seem to understand what he did wrong.

Two people sitting in a kitchen windowsill; a phone with a red lock image is on the window itself

Hulu’s Got To Get Out delivers more comedy and chaos than strategy

My review of Hulu’s Got To Get Out, which has some genuine thrills—and a cast that produces some hilarious and stupid attempts to escape a locked house.

Cover detail from The Bishop and the Butterfly. Does the author over-index the tragic death of Vivian Gordon? (Hachette Book Group)

2025 Edgars round-up: The Bishop and the Butterfly

Susan Howard wraps this year’s Best Fact Crime overview with a look at a Tammany Hall story that may have overreached.

Gloved hands place stacks of money into a wood box

How Million Dollar Secret ended, and why I hope there’s more

Netflix’s Million Dollar Secret ended as strong as it began, with a deceptively simple final task and an impressive win. Here are my thoughts about the season’s end.

A person listening to a chef writes in a notebook

Top Chef’s best decision in years: chefs working in Toronto restaurants

Whole Foods kinda screwed a team on Top Chef: Destination Canada episode 5, but the chefs’ time staging in restaurants was fantastic. My recap!

News & updates

  • Peacock will follow Love Island USA "around Los Angeles as they navigate new careers, evolving friendships, newfound fame and complex relationships outside of the Love Island villa" for a new series, Love Island: Beyond the Villa. Will anyone care to watch Islanders while they're wearing clothes?

  • Padma Lakshmi created and will host a new CBS cooking competition, America's Culinary Cup.

    CBS describes the show, which will air next summer, as "an invitation-only cast of the nation’s most decorated chefs as they embark on a one-of-a-kind competition designed to challenge their creativity, endurance, presentation, leadership and more."

  • Survivor 47’s Teeny Chirichillo wrote in Cosmpolitan about his Survivor experience, and how, while fan response "felt like an extreme pressure to be this genderfluid representative, what it really did was open the door for everyone in my life to know I’m not cisgender without my having to initiate these conversations."

  • How shocking: Mickey Rourke has been booted from the Celebrity Big Brother house for what ITV called "inappropriate language" and "instances of unacceptable behaviour," BBC News reported. He'd previously been warned after using "offensive and unacceptable" language about JoJo Siwa and her sexuality.

  • As a fan of Ramsay's Kitchen Nightmares, I cannot stand Gordon Ramsay's slide into histrionic bullshit.

    So I just rolled my eyes at the latest attempt to one-up this tired formula, Gordon Ramsay’s Secret Service, in which "Gordon Ramsay trades his signature chef knives for a state-of-the-art surveillance vehicle and cutting-edge spyware" and will "infiltrate the restaurant after-hours for a dramatic nighttime black light kitchen investigation."

    But oh, did I laugh and laugh at the fact that Gordon Ramsay is going to use "spyware"—certainly not "spycraft"!—in his new series.

  • David Siegel, a guest on Below Deck, participant in Celebrity Wife Swap, and monstrous star of The Queen of Versailles died April 5.

    His wife Jackie Siegel's sister died two days later. Jackie wrote on Instagram that it was from "a scourge we as a family sadly know too well – accidental drug overdose."

    David and Jackie's daughter Victoria died at 18 from a drug overdose. She was prominently featured in the documentary; if you haven't seen it, it's on Hulu and Hoopla, and free on Tubi until tomorrow.

  • Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio—fresh off of blaming a marketing agency for tweeting banana emojis at Taylor Hale, Big Brother’s first Black female winner, which resulted in Johnny's fans tweeting racist things at her—was the first suitor on Netflix's disastrous attempt at a live version of the YouTube series Pop the Balloon.

    After all the women rejected him, he critiqued them, starting with toes, and told a Black woman, "You look like you sleep from a tree upside down." Decider has clips.

  • Tiffany Derry is MasterChef’s new judge; she's joining the Fox show for season 15 alongside Joe Bastianich and Gordon Ramsay. That may explain why she left Bobby's Triple Threat. The new season is titled MasterChef: Dynamic Duos and features an Amazing Race-like cast of duos.

  • Brent Freeburg is the Below Deck camera operator who saved deckhand Ashton's life when Ashton's foot got caught in a line and was dragged off the boat during season six. This year, he was fighting for his own life.

    In February, Brent was hospitalized, comatose and suffering from strokes and subdural hematoma. Like so many freelancers who work on reality TV shows, he was without insurance. Now he's recovering in a sub-acute care facility. His mother gave a detailed account of his medical ordeals on a GoFundMe page set up to help cover costs of his care.

  • The Rock is writing a true-crime book. "Oh, obviously." Well, actually it does make sense -- Dwayne Johnson is set to star in an upcoming Scorsese pic about Hawaiian OC kingpin Wilford "Nappy" Pulawa; Vanity Fair's Nick Bilton, the screenwriter on that project, is also Johnson's co-author. I'm not super-stoked about all the "can you read what The Rock is writing?" heds that await us, but I'd give the book a look, come the day...

Shows I recommend Extracted on Fox • The Traitors on Peacock

All of this week’s premieres → Reality TV showsspecials and documentaries

recent comments

  1. Avatar for Andy Dehnart
  2. Avatar for Andy Dehnart
  3. Avatar for Andy Dehnart
  4. Avatar for Andy Dehnart
  5. Avatar for Andy Dehnart
  6. Avatar for Andy Dehnart
  7. Avatar for Andy Dehnart
  8. Avatar for Andy Dehnart
  9. Avatar for Andy Dehnart
  10. Avatar for Andy Dehnart

From the archives

Recommended reality TV shows

True crime reviews

Three recommendations, a two-week break

This week: A super-brief episode with three fast recommendations because I cannot actually talk, so apologies for having to listen to 50 seconds of this.

Two people sit on a couch and talk; the person on the left gestures widely
Andy Dehnart’s Reality Blurred
Three recommendations, a two-week break
Loading
/