Tactical Reform in the Late Roman Republic: The View from Italy
Tactical Reform in the Late Roman Republic: The View from Italy
Abstract
This article discusses the organizational and tactical changes in the Roman army during the Late Republic, a transformation often incorrectly dubbed the “Marian reforms.” It suggests that the most notable reform of the period, the rise of the cohortal legion, owed primarily to the influence of the Italian socii, the eventual outcome of recruiting, organizing and deploying allied troops in cohorts during the second and first centuries BC. The four cohorts that fronted a Late Republican legion correspond with the four cohorts of the Italian vanguard, the extraordinarii, suggesting the cohortal legion emerged out of a method of expeditiously deploying an allied wing.
Keywords
legion | cohort | tactics | socii | extraordinarii | Gaius Marius
References
- 1. Anders, Adam 2015. “Face of Skirmish: The Nature and Experience of Skirmishing and Non- Pitched Battle.”
Historia 64, 263-300. - 2. Armstrong, Jeremy 2016.
War and Society in Early Rome: From Warlords to Generals . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. - 3. von Arnim, Herman 1892.
“Ineditum Vaticanum.” Hermes 27, 118-130. - 4. Bell, Michael J. V. 1965. “Tactical Reform in the Roman Republican Army.”
Historia 14, 404-422. - 5. Brunt, Peter 1971.
Italian Manpower . Oxford: Oxford University Press. - 6. Cadiou, Francois 2009. “Le dilectus de l’année 151 et les guerres celtibéro-lusitaniennes.” In Antela-Bernárdez and T. Ñaco del Hoyo (eds.)
Setting landscapes into motion in the Ancient Empires , 23-32. Oxford: BAR International. - 7. Carney, Thomas 1970.
A Biography of C. Marius . Chicago: Argonaut. - 8. Carter, Michael 2006. “Buttons and Wooden Swords: Polybius 10.20.3, Livy 26.51 and the Rudis.”
Classical Philology 101, 153-160. - 9. Connolly, Peter 2000. “The reconstruction and use of Roman weaponry in the second century BC.”
Journal of Roman Military Equipment Studies 11, 43-46. - 10. Timothy, Cornell (ed.) 2013.
Fragments of the Roman Historians . Oxford: Oxford University Press. - 11. Cosme, Pierre 2007.
L’armée romaine. VIIIe s. av. J.-C-Ve s. ap. J.-C . Paris: Armand Colin. - 12. Delbrück, Hans 1920.
Geschichte der Kriegskunst im Rahmen der politischen Geschichte 1 . Verlag von Georg Stilke. - 13. DeLigt, Luuk 2012.
Peasants, Citizens and Soldiers. Studies in the Demographic History of Roman Italy, 225 BC-AD 100 . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. - 14. Dobson, Michael 2008.
The Army of the Roman Republic: The Second Century BC, Polybius and the Camps at Numantia, Spain . Oxford: Oxbow. - 15. von Domaszewski, Alfred 1885.
Die Fahnen im römischen Heere . Vienna: University of Vienna. - 16. Erdkamp, Paul 2006. “Late-Annalistic Battle Scenes in Livy (Books 21-44).”
Mnemosyne 59, 525- 563. - 17. Erdkamp, Paul 2007. “Polybius and Livy on the allies in the Roman Army.” In Lukas DeBlois and Elio Lo Cascio (eds.)
The Impact of the Roman Army (200 BC-AD 476) , 47-74. Brill: Leiden/Boston. - 18. Faure, Patrice 2008 “Les symboles des centuries legionnaires.”
ZPE 165: 293-303. - 19. Flower, Harriet 2008.
Roman Republics . Princeton: Princeton University Press. - 20. Fronda, Michael 2010.
Between Rome and Carthage: Southern Italy during the Second Punic War . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. - 21. Gabba, Emilio 1976.
Republican Rome, the Army and the Allies . Berkeley: University of California Press. - 22. Gilliver, Kate 1999.
The Roman Art of War . Stroud: Tempus. - 23. Gilliver, Kate 2007. “The Augustan Reform and the Structure of the Imperial Army.” In Paul Erdkamp (ed.)
The Companion to the Roman Army , 217-234. Malden: Blackwell. - 24. Goldsworthy, Adrian 1996.
The Roman Army at War: 100 BC-AD 200 . Oxford: Clarendon Press. Theodora Hantos 2003. “Über die Entstehung von Herrschaft (am Beispiel der praefecti socium im römisch-republikanischen Heer.” In Theodora Hantos (ed.)Laurea internationalis: Festschrift für Jochen Bleiken zum 75. Gerburtstag , Stuttgart: Franz Steiner Verlag. - 25. Ilari, Virgilio 1974.
Gli Italici nelle Strutture Militari Romane . Milan: A. Giuffrè. - 26. Isaac, Benjamin 1998.
The Near East Under Roman Rule: Selected Papers . Leiden: Brill. - 27. Jehne, Martin 2006. “Römer, Latiner und Bundesgenossen im Krieg. Zu Formen und Ausmass der Integration in der republikanischen Armee.” In Martin Jehne and Rene Pfeilschifter (eds.)
Herrschaft ohne Integration? Rom und Italien in republikanischer Zeit , 243-268. Frankfurt: Verlag Antike. - 28. Kent, Patrick 2012.
The Roman Army’s Emergence from its Italian Origins . Unpublished PhD Dissertation, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. - 29. Kent, Patrick 2012b. “Reconsidering socii in Roman Armies before the Punic Wars.” In Saskia Roselaar (ed.)
Processes of Integration and Identity formation in the Roman Republic , 71-84. Leiden: Brill. - 30. Keppie, Lawrence 1984.
The Making of the Roman Army: From Republic to Empire . London: Routledge. - 31. Kimmig, Walter 1940. “Ein Keltenschild aus Ägypten.”
Germania 24, 106-111. - 32. Lazenby, John 1978.
Hannibal’s War: A Military History of the Second Punic War . Warminster: Aris and Philips. - 33. Lendon, Jon Edward 2005.
Soldiers and Ghosts: A History of Battle in Classical Antiquity . New Haven: Yale University Press. - 34. Marquardt, Joachim 1876.
Römische Staatsverwaltung 2. Leipzig: Von S. Hirzel. - 35. Mann, John C. 1997. “Roman Legionary Centurial Symbols.”
ZPE 115: 295-298. - 36. Matthew, Christopher 2010a.
On the Wings of Eagles: The Reforms of Gaius Marius and the Creation of Rome’s First Professional Soldiers . Newcastle-upon-Tyne: Cambridge Scholars Publishing. - 37. Matthew, Christopher 2010b. “The Battle of Vercellae and the Modification of the Heavy Javelin (
Pilum ) by Gaius Marius.”Antichthon 44, 50-67. - 38. Mommsen, Theodor 1855.
Romische Geschiste 2. Berlin: Weidmannsche. - 39. Nicolet, Claude 1967. “
Tribuni militum a populo .” Mélanges d‘archéologie et d‘histoire - 40. Nicolet, Claude 1978. “Le Stipendium des allies italiens avant la Guerre sociale.”
Papers of the British School in Rome 46, 1-11. - 41. Parker, Henry 1928.
The Roman Legions . Oxford: Clarendon Press. - 42. Paul, George 1984.
A Historical Commentary on Sallust’s Bellum Jugurthinum . Liverpool: F. Cairns. - 43. Pfeilschifter, Rene 2007. “The allies in the Republican army and the Romanization of Italy.” In R. Roth and J. Keller (eds.)
Roman by Integration: Dimensions of Group Identity in Material Culture and Text (JRA Supplementary Series Number 66) , 27-42. Ann Arbor: Cushing-Malloy. - 44. Potter, David 2004. “The Roman Army and Navy.” In Harriet Flower (ed.)
The Cambridge Companion to the Roman Republic , 54-77. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. - 45. Potter, David 2010. “Caesar and the Helvetians.” In Garett Fagan and Matthew Trundle (eds.)
New Perspectives on Ancient Warfare , 304-329. Leiden: Brill. - 46. Quesada-Sanz, Fernando 1997. “
Gladius hispaniensis : An archaeological view from Iberia.”Journal of Roman Military Equipment Studies 8, 251-270. - 47. Quesada-Sanz, Fernando 2006. “Not so different: individual fighting techniques and small unit tactics of Roman and Iberian armies within the framework of warfare in the Hellenistic Age”
Pallas 70, 245-263. - 48. Rankov, Boris 2007. “Military Forces.” In Philip Sabin, Hans Van Wees and Michael Whitby (eds)
The Cambridge History of Greek and Roman Warfare 2, 31-75. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. - 49. Rawlings, Louis 2007. “Army and Battle During the Conquest of Italy.” In Paul Erdkamp (ed.)
A Companion to the Roman Army , 45-62. Malden: Wiley Blackwell. - 50. Rawson, Elizabeth 1971. “The Literary Sources for the Pre-Marian Army.”
Papers of the British School at Rome 49, 13-31. - 51. Rich, John 1983 “The Supposed Roman Manpower Shortage of the Later Second Century B. C.”
Historia 32, 287-331. - 52. Rosenstein, Nathan 2012. “Integration and Armies in the Middle Republic.” In Saskia Roselaar (ed.)
Processes of Integration and Identity Formation in the Roman Republic , 85-104. Leiden: Brill. - 53. Roth, Jonathan 1994. “The Size and Organization of the Roman Imperial Legion.”
Historia 43, 346-362. - 54. Rüstow, Wilhelm 1862.
Heerwesen und Kriegführung C. Julius Cäsars . Nordhausen: F. Föstermann. - 55. Sage, Michael 2013a. “The Rise of Rome.” In B. Campbell and L. Tritle (eds.)
The Oxford Handbook of Warfare in the Classical World , 216-235. Oxford: Oxford University Press. - 56. Sage, Michael 2013b. “
Extraordinarii .” In R. Bagnall, K. Brodersen, et al.The Encyclopedia of Ancient History , 2006-07. Malden: Blackwell. - 57. Scullard, Howard H. 1970.
Scipio Africanus: Soldier and Politician . Ithaca: Cornell University Press. - 58. Sekunda, Nicholas 1996.
Republican Roman Army 200-104 BC . Oxford: Osprey. - 59. Smith, Richard 1958.
Service in the Post-Marian Army . New York: Barnes and Noble. - 60. Speidel, Michael P. 2002. “The Framework of an imperial legion.” In Richard Brewer (ed.)
Birthday of the Eagle: The Second Augustan Legion and the Roman Military Machine . Cardiff: National Museum and Galleries of Wales. - 61. Speidel, Michael P. 2005. “Centurial Signs and the Order of the Legions.”
ZPE 154: 286-292. - 62. Suolahti, Jaakko 1955.
The junior officers of the Roman army in the Republican period: a study on social structure . Helsinki: Suomalainen Tiedeakatemia. - 63. Taylor, Lily Ross 1925. “Horace’s Equestrian Career.”
American Journal of Philology 46, 161-70. - 64. Taylor, Lily Ross 2014. “Roman Infantry Tactics in the Mid-Republic: A Reassessment.”
Historia 63, 301-322. - 65. Taylor, Lily Ross 2014/15. “Visual Evidence for Roman Infantry Tactics.”
Memoirs of the American Academy in Rome 59/60, 103-120. - 66. Taylor, Lily Ross 2017. “Etruscan Identity and Service in the Roman Army.”
American Journal of Archaeology 121: 275-292. - 67. Wheeler, Everett 1979. “The Legion as Phalanx.”
Chiron 9: 303-18. - 68. Veith, Georg 1907. “Die Taktik der Kohortenlegion.”
Klio 7, 303-334. - 69. Verchère de Reffye, Jean Baptiste 1864. “Les Armes d’Alise.”
Revue Archéologique 10, 337-349. - 70. Votch, Wilhelm 1886.
Cajus Marius als Reformator des röm. Heerwesens . Berlin: C. Habel. - 71. Zmodikov, Alexander 2000. “Roman Republican Heavy Infantrymen in battle (IV-II Centuries BC).
Historia 49, 67-78.